Mega high-yield savings accounts are a topic I’ve dealt with in great detail on this blog (a full list of previous posts I’ve written about this topic can be found at the end of this post).
What counts as a mega high-yield savings account might vary depending on who you ask, but my definition is that a mega high-yield savings account is a savings account that offers 5% or more interest. Generally, these accounts are more restrictive than regular savings accounts, usually requiring some work to set up, as well as limiting the amount of money that you can have earning 5% or more interest.
Over the past few years, these accounts haven’t been very useful since interest rates have been high and it’s been possible to get around 5% interest without going through the hassles of these mega high-yield accounts. Indeed, I ended up moving most of the money I had in my mega high-yield savings accounts to Raisin since it was easier for me to have my emergency fund all in one place (you can read my full review on Raisin here).
That being said, I never closed my mega high-yield savings accounts since I suspected that rates might fall one day and I wanted to maintain access to these 5% interest accounts if rates did drop. To avoid inactivity fees, I’ve continued to automate monthly transfers in and out of the accounts.
And sure enough, over the past few months, we’ve started to see rates drop. While we might never get back to the extremely low-interest rate environment we used to be in, we may be reaching the point where it’s worth considering these mega high-yield savings accounts again,
It’s been a while since I’ve looked at what’s been going on with these mega high-yield savings accounts, so in this post, I wanted to review the current landscape of these accounts and discuss what my plans with these accounts are going forward.
The Current Landscape of Mega High-Yield Savings Accounts
At the time I write this, I see 8 mega high-yield savings accounts that are still around. These include the five flavors of Netspend accounts, as well as DCU, Service Credit Union, and H-E-B Debit. All of these accounts pay at least 5%, with several paying 6% interest.
Of these accounts, DCU is the easiest one to get started with since it doesn’t require any special setup process and has no fees or minimum balance requirements to worry about. The account offers 6% interest on up to $1,000. There’s also the potential for a small signup bonus if you open an account using a referral link (here’s a post I wrote about how to earn a DCU referral bonus if you are interested).
Service Credit Union is the next easiest mega high-yield savings account, offering 5% interest on their primary savings account. Like DCU, Service Credit Union also doesn’t require any special setup procedure and it has no fees or minimum balance requirements. The big downside with Service Credit Union is that the savings account only pays 5% interest on the first $500 in the account, which limits its usefulness (for a detailed look at Service Credit Union, here’s a post I wrote about Service Credit Union several years ago).
After those two credit union accounts, the remaining accounts are prepaid debit card accounts that offer a savings account with them. These accounts all require some initial setup work to avoid fees and require a bit of understanding as to how they work.
The first of these accounts is the H-E-B Debit account, which offers 6% interest on up to $2,000. This account is probably the best of this type of account because of the high interest rate and the higher cap on what can earn the 6% interest. You can learn more about how the H-E-B Debit account works in this post I wrote: The H-E-B Debit Card 6% Interest Savings Account.
After that, you are looking at the Netspend cards. There are multiple “flavors” of these cards and everyone should be able to open at least four of them, with most people able to open five of them.
Of the various Netspend cards, the regular Netspend card is the first one most people will start with. This card is interesting because it used to limit users to 5% interest on up to $1,000. However, at some point in the past year, it appears they quietly increased the savings account to 6% interest on the first $2,000.
The other Netspend cards include the Ace Elite, Western Union, H-E-B Prepaid (not to be confused with the H-E-B Debit discussed above), and Brinks. Each of those Netspend cards gives you a 5% interest savings account on up to $1,000. So with all four of those cards, you’d be able to deposit up to $4,000 earning 5% interest. (Note, these Netspend cards come with a lot of initial setup work, so you’ll want to read my post: Netspend Account: The Ultimate Guide to a 5% Interest Savings Account.
Are They Worth It?
If you’re able to max out each of the mega high-yield savings accounts discussed above, you’ll be able to set aside $9,500 earning 5% or more interest. If you’re a two-person household, you can set up accounts for each person in your household, increasing the amount you can save to $19,000. For most people, that’s probably an excellent emergency fund.
Back when interest rates were at 1% or less, I thought it was a no-brainer for most people to set these accounts up, even with all the hassle that went along with it. A two-person household with $19,000 in regular savings accounts earning 1% interest would earn just $190 per year of interest. In contrast, $19,000 earning around 5% interest came out to $950 in a year – a sum that seemed significant enough that I thought it was worth doing.
Once interest rates went to 4% or higher, the math changed. At one point, Raisin (which is a high-yield savings account option that I use), had accounts offering over 5%, so it made no sense to deal with the mega high-yield options when you could just get 5% or more from Raisin without any hassle. Rates have been dropping though, with your typical high-yield savings account offering around 4% interest now.
With a 4% interest rate, you’d earn $760 per year in interest on $19,000, in contrast to the $950 per year you’d get if you maximized for the 5% interest rate options. Personally, I don’t think it’s worth the hassle of opening these accounts if the difference in interest is just $100 or $200 per year. Where I’d start to consider these accounts more is if the interest rates start dropping down into the 3% range. At that point, you’re looking at a bigger spread that might justify the initial setup work.
All of this mainly depends on whether or not you already have these accounts open. If you’ve already set up these accounts, then maintaining them shouldn’t require any work on your end assuming you’ve automated the monthly transfers in and out of the account to avoid inactivity fees.
One thing to note is that Netspend changed the inactivity time limit, changing it from 90 days to 60 days. So, if you want to avoid inactivity fees, I’d recommend you have your automated transfer into and out of the account going monthly, rather than bi-monthly or quarterly. I now have it set up so my Netspend accounts have $1 going into them at the beginning of each month, then $1 getting pulled out at the end of the month.
My Plans Going Forward
Right now, I’m doing a bit of a hybrid approach, taking advantage of the DCU and H-E-B Debit accounts since they both pay 6% interest, but not doing anything with the 5% accounts. I still keep all of my accounts open because I’ve already automated everything, but if it ever became difficult to avoid fees on the Netspend cards, I’d close them. However, since it’s not hard to keep my accounts open and fee-free, there’s no reason to close them.
If rates for regular high-yield savings accounts do drop, I may consider maxing out all of these 5% interest accounts, but right now, I’m fine with just using the DCU and H-E-B Debit accounts. I haven’t gotten around to putting money back into my regular Netspend account even though it appears to pay 6% interest now, mainly because I’ve been too lazy to deal with moving the money into it, but also because I’m not quite clear if it’s actually paying 6% interest. I have a sneaking suspicion that the Netspend account I have might still only pay 5% interest and that the 6% interest account is a different product or only for new customers.
The big question you might have is whether it’s worth dealing with these accounts if you haven’t opened them yet. In my opinion, it’s probably still not worth dealing with these accounts if you haven’t opened them yet – the difference in interest rates between these accounts and a regular high-yield savings account isn’t worth it.
That being said, if you’re someone who really likes to optimize things, I’d say it’s probably worth opening a DCU account since that account is easy to open and doesn’t require any management on your end. I wouldn’t deal with the hassle of opening the others though until rates drop significantly. For me, interest rates need to drop to 3% or lower before I’d deal with the hassle of opening up these mega high-yield savings accounts.
Final Thoughts
Interest rates being where they are now is nice, as it makes it easier to deal with your cash. Back when rates were at 1% or less, holding cash often didn’t feel great, as even large amounts didn’t feel like much, so these accounts made a lot of sense. Today, these mega high-yield savings accounts aren’t really that important.
I’m still keeping these accounts open unless something changes with the fee structure. But since I’ve automated everything, I don’t even have to look at the accounts.
If you want to learn more about how these accounts work, I’ve got a lot of posts I’ve written about them over the years, so check them out if you’re interested.
- Where To Get 5% Interest Savings Accounts
- Netspend Account: The Ultimate Guide to a 5% Interest Savings Account
- DCU $20 Referral Bonus – Step By Step Guide (Plus A 6% Interest Savings Account)
- The H-E-B Debit Card 6% Interest Savings Account
- Service Credit Union – A Mega-High-Yield Savings Account For Up To $3,500
Dan says
NetSpend told me that my cards are all still at 5% apy because that’s what they were opened at, and that I cannot benefit from the 6% apy up to $2000.00 balance in any of them (other than the HEB Savings mentioned). I tried to check the statements, but it doesn’t tell me how much the interest apy is.
Has anyone figured out if maybe what they told me was incorrect, and that we are in fact getting 6% and able to increase each balance to $2000?
dan says
Correction: The Quarterly statement for October does list the interest rate still only at 5.05% APY.
I’m wondering whether we should close each and reopen each to obtain the higher interest and higher balance. Any idea?
Sly One says
That’s a good question Dan. I’m waiting to look at the next quarterly statement and see if the interest rate is updated to 6% on $2,000(As it should be). It seems strange that you can only have one Netspend card and that the savings rates would be different on the same card. I also heard that you can have a second H-E-B 6% on $2,000 card. I may try that instead of closing and re-opening my existing Netspend card if the rate is still 5% on $1,000. Seems like less work.
To complicate matters further some fine print mentions having to have an “all access” account which has a non refundable $5 monthly fee while other links mentioning the 6% on $2,000 mention nothing about haven an “all access” account. Like this link here: https://www.netspend.com/savings-account
If you scroll to the bottom there is nothing about having to have an “all access” account.
Sly One says
Well I just checked my quarterly Netspend savings account statement today and nothing has changed. It still says 5% on $1,000. So it looks like they are not going to update existing users to the new rate. Either that or the 6% is only for those having the “all access” account. It would be nice if their customer service would clarify this rather than sending me to their FAQ section which does not address this concern.
Tim Holmes says
Vanguard‘s federal money market investor is paying 4.57% so from my time it’s not worth messing with all the companies that cap your interest at such small amounts. Empower Personal Capital is still paying 4% but it’s been coming down.
Judy Jones says
Newtek bank is still 4.9% no limit and no hoops and no fees.
Financial Panther says
Nice. Do you know if that rate has been historically that high or does it tend to move up and down with rates? Any regional limitations on this bank account? I’ve never heard of it, so wonder if it’s only available in certain geographic areas and/or the rate isn’t typically so high.