Table of Contents
One of the things I’ve noticed about the FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) community is that we all tend to be naturally environmentally friendly – it seems to be a byproduct of the lifestyle choices that we make. Take me as an example. I bike to work, keep my heat turned down fairly low during the winter, and when I do drive, I drive a Prius.
I don’t necessarily do these things for the environmental benefits – it’s mainly because these things save me money and help me avoid getting soft and weak. But the fact that they tend to have a positive environmental impact isn’t a bad byproduct either.
Some time ago, I saw an ad on Facebook for a company called Arcadia Power, which promised me that if I signed up for their service, I could get 50% of my home’s electricity sourced from wind power at no additional cost and without having to switch my electricity company. This piqued my interest – I’m all for doing something free and that gives me an advantage in some way. But was Arcadia Power legit or was Arcadia Power a scam?
Note: Unfortunately, as of November 2020, Arcadia Power has removed the free option, which means the only option is the paid option that sources 100% of your energy from renewable resources. I’ll go into more detail about the pricing later in this post.
I’ve been an Arcadia Power customer now for over a year and after using it for so long without any issues, I definitely think it’s legit and something worth using, hence why I’m writing up this Arcadia Power review. If you have any interest at all in supporting renewable energy sources, signing up for Arcadia Power is an easy way to do just that.
For a limited time, if you sign up for Arcadia Power through my link, you’ll get $25 towards your first utility bill after you link your electricity company to Arcadia.
How Electricity Works In The US
To understand what Arcadia Power is, you have to first understand a little bit about how electricity works in the United States. We get our electricity from a lot of different sources here – coal, nuclear, solar, wind, hydroelectric, etc. Once electricity gets generated, it gets sent to the national power grid, which then sends the electricity to our homes via power lines.
What this means is that once electricity is made, there’s no real way to differentiate different types of electricity – it all looks the same once it enters the power grid, sort of like how a cup of water looks the same as any other water once you dump it into a river. Unless you’re generating your own electricity (such as via solar panels on your house), there’s no way to actually know or say where your electricity came from.
That’s where Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) come into play. Every time one megawatt-hour of renewable electricity is generated, a REC is also created. RECs basically serve as a way to “prove” that the power in your home is coming from a renewable energy source. So, you end up buying two things when you buy electricity from a renewable energy source – the electricity that was generated from it and the REC that gets created with it.
For more info about RECs, check out this short primer here from the EPA. Below is also a great video that I think really breaks down the whole REC system:
To be fair, RECs aren’t all sunshine and rainbows. There are some legitimate criticisms about RECs as a way to promote renewable energy, mainly around the argument that they cost too little to actually encourage companies to build renewable energy projects. REC supporters, on the other hand, point out that there aren’t really any other systems that can work based on how we currently get our electricity from the power grid.
That debate is way beyond the subject of this post, but if you’re looking for further reading about RECs, feel free to check out the below links:
- https://www.vox.com/2015/11/9/9696820/renewable-energy-certificates
- https://www.technologyreview.com/s/542036/defending-renewable-energy-certificates/
- https://thinkprogress.org/clean-energy-trainwreck-why-most-recs-are-bad-and-how-to-find-the-good-ones-63975573c073/
The main thing to consider, I think, is that by getting RECs, you can at least support renewable energy in some way. I’d say, at a minimum, that’s better than sitting around doing nothing.
How Does Arcadia Power Work?
With that background out of the way, let’s talk about how Arcadia Power works. Here’s an explainer video that comes directly from Arcadia Power:
In short, when you become an Arcadia Power customer, Arcadia Power will buy RECs on your behalf, which means that your electricity will be attributable to renewable energy sources.
If you’re worried that this sounds like work, just know that it’s not. When you sign up with Arcadia Power, you do not change your current electricity provider. Whatever electricity company you have now is the electricity company you will continue to have. You don’t have to do anything beyond setting up your Arcadia Power account.
Instead, Arcadia Power works on top of your current electricity company. They used to offer two plans, a free one and a paid one. As of November 2020, Arcadia Power has removed the free option and now only offers a paid option that sources 100% of your energy from renewable energy sources for a flat $5 per month. Depending on how much your electricity bill is, this can actually be cheaper than the typical way of paying for RECs, which are paid for via the amount of electricity you use.
There are no contracts to worry about, so you’re not on the hook for anything if you sign up for Arcadia Power and decide later that it’s not for you.
Once you sign up, you’ll be directed to link your current electric utility account with Arcadia Power and you’ll also get to choose how you want to pay your bill – either by credit card or with a bank withdrawal. Paying with your credit card is free, so I highly recommend using a credit card so that you can get some rewards points.
After those steps are completed, every time you receive your bill from your electricity company, Arcadia Power will get your bill from them, charge your card or bank account, and then pay your electricity company on your behalf.
You’re essentially setting up a new autopay with Arcadia Power. Think of it as looking like this:
Bank Account –> Arcadia Power –> Your Electric Company
I checked my bill when I first signed up just to make sure there wasn’t an upcharge and my bill was the same as the bill I received from my electricity company. All that happened is that my autopay is now going to Arcadia Power, instead of my regular electric company. And as a benefit, I get the satisfaction of knowing that I’m supporting renewable energy sources. It’s also easier to have my electricity bill get charged to my credit card.
The Arcadia Power Dashboard
Beyond just the environmental benefits, another benefit of signing up for Arcadia Power is access to a much better online dashboard. I’ve probably looked at my utility company’s online dashboard a handful of times in my life, but the Arcadia Power dashboard has so much info in it that I keep coming back to look at it.
Remember though that you can still go and look at your normal dashboard with your electricity company, so it’s not like you lose access to what you already have. By signing up for Arcadia Power, you’re basically just adding a new dashboard that has a lot more useful info.
One feature I like on my online dashboard is this energy usage chart:
There’s also a very cool section where I can see what percentage of my power came from different energy sources:
As you can see in the above screenshot, a little over half of my energy can be attributed to renewable energy sources. I’m not quite sure how Arcadia Power knows where the other sources of my energy came from – I’m guessing they use averages or something – but I can at least be confident that half of my energy came from renewable sources.
The reason I know that is because, in addition to my power bill, I also received the below REC, which certifies that 159 kWh of my electricity in the past month came from renewable energy sources. That’s half of my electricity consumption for the month. (Note: This was back when I was on the free plan, which gave me 50% of my energy from renewable energy sources at no cost to me).
Finally, Arcadia Power also has a great app where you can see your electricity bills and check out your energy usage. What’s most helpful is just being able to easily look at my past statements so I can see how my electricity usage has been trending.
Takeaways
If you are interested in supporting renewable energy, signing up for Arcadia Power can make a lot of sense. Arcadia Power made a lot of sense when they had their free plan that cost nothing to use. At $5 per month, you’ll have to decide if this is something that makes sense for you. (When I first wrote this post, I predicted that the free plan probably wouldn’t last forever – it looks like I was right)
One thing to consider (that isn’t really a problem, in my opinion) is that Arcadia Power pays your electricity bill as soon as it receives it. That means that some people will be paying their electricity bills a little earlier than they’re used to. This isn’t a big problem for most of us, but it’s something to consider if you’re the type that likes to pay your bill on a specific day of the month. If you’re using a credit card to pay your bill (which you should since it’s free to use your credit card), then this actually won’t matter at all, since if you’re like most people, you probably just pay your credit card bill on the same day each month anyway. I think Arcadia Power was also looking at this issue because they added a “delay payment” button which allows you to delay your payment date to a later date. I haven’t used this feature since I don’t have much reason to use it, but it’s nice to know that it’s there.
Arcadia Power also might not be available everywhere, so you’ll have to see if your zip code is supported. They do say that they’re available in all 50 states, but there may be certain zip codes that aren’t able to access Arcadia Power, for whatever reason.
If you’re interested in signing up for Arcadia Power, be sure to use this referral link and you’ll get $25 towards your first utility bill.
Let me know how Arcadia Power works for you or if you’re considering any other ways to support renewable energy sources!
They promissed an immediate $50 gift for signing up… but then they charged $49 to my credit card…!!!
No gift reward!! Smells bad on a Sunday! Brock said they will contact me Monday.
The ladies that came to my house they did my changed my electric company user name and changed the password so they can link it with arcadia. I found that so disrespectful and unprofessional. I’m having my doubts. So I think I will cancel both.. my cc and this place
I was just checking my Arcadia account statement last night and noticed the format had changed. That always prompts me to do a google search about changes to Arcadia. I’m sure they communicate changes to their plans and offerings, the thing is I’m terrible about actually reading emails once an account is on autopilot. That being said, I’ve been an Arcadia customer for years now and things have certainly changed, but never in a way that negatively impacts me. I joined the free 50% renewable plan back in the day. I haven’t seen any mentions in your post or comments about how people on those 50% plans were transferred to the now universal 100% renewable plan. I suspect it is specific to the laws in each state, but my plan was converted to a 100% renewable supply (with monthly RECs supplied to prove it) but remains free to this day. And I can verify that a charge is not hidden somewhere simply by checking the bill from my supplier that Arcadia pays on my behalf (and charges my credit card). Just curious if this was standard or if most legacy 50%-renewable-account-holders are now billed the monthly fee? In joining Arcadia your motivation definitely needs to be the larger long term environmental impact and the hope that your socially responsible action is noticed and helps to convince one or two others to do the same. All while being no worse off financially. If you’re looking for a huge financial saving, you’ll most certainly be disappointed. Glad I came across your post. I subscribed. Looking forward to reading many more!
Thanks for this. With your referral link I was able to sign up for free 50% program for Southern Nevada. Without link it only allowed me to join the $5/month program. I guess they haven’t fully implemented the paid program everywhere.
It’s interesting that they factor in how much state generates from renewables. For Nevada, NV Energy produces about 26% of their power from renewables so they are only providing and additional 37% (50% of 74) making it 63%. They’re mandated to go up to 50% by 2030 at which point it’ll be 75% for me. I already have solar but system was bought before we added 2 EVs to household. With this free program I’m going from about 74% to 87% renewable.
The $5/month program is not bad. Average household uses about 1 mWh or 1 REC per month. You can buy a REC from Terra Pass for $5 so same price for average home plus ability to pay bill with credit card for points. Old program of $0.015/kWh was a horrible deal at $15/mWh/REC (could be seen as $30/mWh/REC since half was free). It’s probably how they subsidize all the free users along with the float on our money.
Have you tried their community solar program ? I wish I can get feedback from someone who has tried it. It says if I invest in 1 panel at $100 I will get $12 back discount on my bill each month or $120 over the course of 10 years. To me that’s a great way to support renewable energy even though it only nets me 2% APY . However the key word ” on average” I will get back $12 per month . So that’s the only part that makes me iffy about trying their community solar program.
I haven’t unfortunately. If you learn anything about it, would definitely like to hear your experience.
Please feel free to share the email I just sent you re: Arcadia Power and Nexamp.
This was mentioned in the very first comment on this blog post four years ago. It averages to $1/month, not $12/month. Can you commit to keeping the service for 10 years? If you move to somewhere that includes electricity, you can’t benefit from your long-ago- paid for virtual panel. Also, Arcadia no longer has the free wind plans, so you have to spend money to even to get your tiny discount. Kinda shady if you ask me.
Despite what you say, being an Arcadia participant makes NOT CHANGE to the source of the power than comes to your home. They do encourage alternate power generation with REC purchases. There are other ESCOs that do the same thing.
Right, you can only get the actual source of power directly from renewable energy if you have your own solar or wind and are not using power from the regular power grid. But as I hopefully explained, the point of RECs is to “purchase” that power. Maybe its a crappy policy, but its the best we have right now if you’re getting power from the grid.
I have been pondering and going back and forth between Arcadia and Solar Farms NY. I’m surprised not see one comment about the Solar Farms NY option. I learned a great deal of information reading your Blog. Do you have any knowledge about
Solar Farms NY in Dryden NY?
Regards
I don’t know anything about Solar Farms NY. That sounds pretty local to your area, so you’ll probably need to ask folks in your area to learn more about it
Kevin, please help me understand what the benefit of paying my bill via Arcadia is? They get the use of my money from autopay date until they pay off my bill. The cc payment option doesn’t appeal to me. How does this middleman help lower my electric bill?
Mike, they make their money from the temporary use of your money. This is called “float” in the financial industry. American Express is an excellent example of a company that makes its profits from “float”. When you buy American Express Traveler’s Checks, you buy them for cash … or credit; the point is that they receive money from you. It may be weeks before you actually use the checks. During that period, Amexco is holding your money without paying you any interest or fee. Your $1,000 of checks may not seem like much but imagine that 500,000 people like you possess a similar amount of Amexco Traveler’s Checks at any given time; that’s $1/2 Billion. They loan, invest and otherwise profit from this money during the temporary period that they are holding your money.
As to the benefits to you, they are: 1) they can (and do) negotiate to buy REC’s ( renewable power) at lower rates and 2) they shift your power usage to renewable sources like wind and solar. That performs some important functions: it makes these energy sources more efficient and profitable in the energy marketplace, which helps them attract more investment capital. It also gives them a bigger share of the energy market, which helps them build legitimacy, obtain subsidies and other benefits. Finally, and most importantly, it reduces our dependence on the fossil fuels that are destabilizing the climate of this planet. All in all, not a bad deal.
I’m convinced by your explanation and the Sierra Club’s endorsement to join, but no thank you to the $20 gift card from Amazon.com. I believe in shopping local, which is harder to do in a small city due to the invasion of the big box stores over the years. Also, Amazon is on my EVIL CORPORATION LIST along with Google, Facebook and Walmart. I did subscribe to your financial newsletter. Thanks.
That’s cool. Gotta stick with your principles.
Where and who generates the renewable energy? Is Arcadia just passing money around or do they actually have solar/wind farms?
This confuses me.
There are so many scams out there that I need more time to look into this.
No, they don’t own the wind farms. When renewable energy is generated, it gets sent to the power grid. All electricity in the power grid is indistinguishable from the other. So, when renewable energy is generated, it also generated a corresponding REC. When you buy a REC, it corresponds with that energy that was generated.
It’s explained pretty well in the post and cites other sources as well that might explain how RECs work better than I can. Hope that helps.
Do you work for Arcadia? They are a rip off an d have many many complaints re cost and failure to cancel accounts.
No, I don’t work for Arcadia. Do you know how a blog works?
And what the heck are you talking about? Arcadia is free, so why are you complaining about cost? Have you ever even used Arcadia or did you even read my post?
Current promotion through 7/31/19 is a Google Home. I just signed up this month.
Hi. I’m on the verge of signing up for community solar but back out every time I get to the page that asks for my power company login credentials. That goes against every paranoid internet user bone in my body. Did you do that when you signed up?
I signed up under you! I love that I can auto-pay through a credit card (free flight points) and was lucky that Arcadia linked up with my power company. Tried to refer my parents and their city forces payments to go through the town hall or some nonsense.
Sweet! Yeah, paying with credit card makes this pretty smart to do, in my opinion. I’ve been using Arcadia now for a while with no problems.
Honestly, I signed up with Arcadia Power initially and their information seems to indicate that their customer base is how they gauge desire to use clean/renewable energy, but I had to cancel my account when they told me they REQUIRED autopay. I have paid my bills every month in a timely manner and I pay them all on the same day, this is a convenience for me and confirms I get my bills paid at the same time. I would prefer to use Arcadia Power, but the need for them to control when they get paid is a real turn off to me. Hopefully they will come up with a non-autopay option in the future and I can opt back in.
Yeah, if you’re not interested in autopay, then Arcadia won’t work out well for you. I noted that this can be an issue for some people – I’m pretty similar in that I prefer manually paying all of my bills on the same day (1st of the month) using the Prism app.
One thing to consider – you can link a credit card to Arcadia and pay via credit card. By doing that, you’re basically going to be able to continue “manually” paying your bills since it’ll now just be a charge on your credit card. Arcadia charges my credit card mid-month for my electric bill. I pay my credit card on the 1st of each month. So it’s essentially the same thing.
Hey, I signed up for this service yesterday following your link and linked my electric utility to the Arcadia website. I was just wondering when I would receive the $20 amazon gift card. Thanks for all the tips and articles on your site!
Hey Stuart. Not sure how long it takes, but probably takes more than 1 day. Just keep an eye on your email and if they never send it to you, reach out to them.
If I am currently enrolled to receive paper statements with my energy company, will I continue to receive paper statements once I sign up with Arcadia Power? From what I’ve been reading, Arcadia takes over your energy account, including changing the login info. I would like to continue to receive my paper statements in the mail.
Hmm…I’m not sure. I never ask for paper statements since I don’t like the clutter. They don’t change the log-in info. You just link your account.
I like the idea of using Arcadia Power for the following reasons:
1) I off-set at least some of my carbon footprint,
2) I pay my bill with a credit card and getting “free” reward points;
3) I have a nice Dashboard to monitor my electric usage.
4) I don’t have to put Solar panels on my house and remove them when I need new shingles.
The ONLY disadvantage I see is that, unlike getting my own rooftop or backyard solar panels, I cannot “fix” my cost and realize the long term savings on power costs. My current provider gets increases which amounts to almost 3% per year! One solar company showed me I could save $27,000 over the next 20 years if I put up panels (with a payoff in about 8 years). I would LOVE to invest in community solar, but it is not available where I live. Is there a way to invest in Arcadia to fix the cost of electricity?
Unfortunately, at least based on how I’m using Arcadia, I don’t think it really does anything to fix the cost of your electricity. You’re still just using electricity from the regular power grid, just offsetting it with RECs.
Sounds fantastic! However is there any non-autopay method to pay Arcadia each month? Their website doesn’t mention it, but wanted to check if anyone else has done it.
I have different cards offering discounts on Utilities in different quarters, and consider autopay to be a hassle, preferring to keep the payment date in my control.
I don’t think there is a non-autopay option. If you use Arcadia, you have to do auto-pay I believe.
I’m very interested, but concerned about this statement in their terms, under the Supplier Brokerage agreement. If I do the 50% free plan, I don’t want them signing me up for any long-term contracts. Am I giving up that right? If not, I’d be in.
You grant Arcadia Power your explicit, informed, and affirmative consent to initiate service and enroll you with a Supplier, and you authorize Arcadia Power to grant your explicit, informed, and affirmative consent to a Supplier on your behalf. You understand and agree that any such enrollment and initiation of service will occur automatically without your additional consent.
By enrolling in our Supplier Brokerage Service, you expressly authorize Arcadia Power to sign Supplier contracts, including community solar subscription agreements, on your behalf. You agree that Arcadia Power may sign such contracts or agreements on your behalf with the signature
I think that has to do with where they get their RECs and things like that, or where they get their solar power if you do that. You don’t change your electricity company on your end – like it’s still with your normal electricity company. It’s not like they can call up xcel energy or whatever and cancel your electricity.
Yeah you literally just give them your login to your electric company’s website and they forward the bills to their e-mail and setup their own payment method. They can’t hijack your electric bill. If you don’t want to use them you can just login and change the password.
Could you end up paying more for each unit of electricity with Arcadia in comparison to regular power company ?
If you’re on the free Arcadia plan, then no, it costs exactly the same.
Thanks for this write-up! However, one thing to note about your suggestion on what payment account to use – it seems that they do NOT charge a credit card fee, so the argument to use Arcadia Power is that much stronger since you can get points/rewards/miles/cashback for your utility bill.
Good point and thanks for the reminder to udpate this post. At the time I wrote this, they weren’t offering free credit card payment options yet, so I was just doing ACH drafting. Since they changed that, I’ve been using my credit card as well to pay.
I jt sign up and asked me for my cc.. they told is to verified is me enrolling. Found out in their my dashboard they linked my electric company with arcadia. 2nd I got a surprised that now as soon the bill comes 3 days after they are they are gonna auto payment Wich I never been told that and this ppl came to my home lied on that. I wanna have the opportunity to choose how I pay the bills. So I think I will cancel
lmy CC & drop from this place
“At this point, I’m not quite sure how they’re able to offer the free plan. ”
If they are paying the bill as soon as they receive it, as you said, then they are using the float to make money off the free plan: they get the money from you right away, pay the bill on the due date, and pool all the money from all customers to generate interest that way.
I was wondering how they could be an actual viable business. This makes sense.
I signed up directly with Arcadia in November, and they gave me a $20.00 credit on my first monthly bill. Sounds a bit better than your $5.00 offer.
Offers change I imagine. Maybe I’ll reach out to Arcadia and see if they’ll match that old offer. I just am using the link I have.
Wish you used my link instead of the generic FB ad! I tweeted it a few times. 😀 I’ve also posted it at MMM forums, I’m surprised nobody ever bites on it. I actually ordered some “community solar” through them as well. And if you’re in a state with deregulated electricity, they automate the process of looking for the best deal.
With the solar, you get a $25 discount per panel, so you’re paying $75 upfront to receive an average $1/mo per month credit for the next 10 years. I don’t know how that compares to actual solar, But paying $75 today to receive a free $45 over time is a lot better than keeping cash in a savings account.
Thanks for that info TJ! Bummer, if I had known about your link I would’ve definitely used it!
Where do you find the discount on solar panels? This article is the only place on the internet I see it mentioned.
That was obviously a temporary promotion.